"The Pale Blue Eye" is a fictional story inspired by real events. It revolves around a series of murders at West Point in 1830 and features a young Edgar Allan Poe as a character. While the film incorporates elements from historical events, including Poe's time at the military academy, the plot and characters are largely fictionalized. The narrative explores themes of mystery and the macabre, reflecting Poe's literary style, but it is not a direct account of true events.

"The Pale Blue Eye," directed by Scott Cooper and based on the novel by Louis Bayard, has received mixed reviews from critics and audiences. The film features a strong performance by Christian Bale as a detective investigating a series of murders at West Point in the 1830s, with a young Edgar Allan Poe, played by Harry Melling, as his aide. The movie is praised for its atmospheric cinematography and period detail, but some viewers find the pacing slow. Overall, it appeals to fans of gothic mysteries and historical dramas.

In "The Pale Blue Eye," the plot twist reveals that the character Edgar Allan Poe, who is assisting in a series of murders at West Point, has a deeper connection to the crimes. It is ultimately uncovered that the real murderer is not just a random figure but is linked to Poe’s own past and the traumatic events he faced. The story intertwines themes of guilt, loss, and the darker aspects of the human psyche, leading to a chilling conclusion that questions the nature of innocence and complicity.

No, Edgar Allan Poe did not write "The Pale Blue Eye." The film, released in 2022, is based on a novel of the same name by Louis Bayard. The story is a fictional mystery set in 1830, involving a detective who enlists Poe, a young cadet at West Point, to help solve a series of murders. Poe's character is inspired by the real-life author, but the novel and film are original works created by Bayard and adapted for the screen.