Born in Pompton Plains, New Jersey, he made his television debut at age five in a commercial before landing roles in soap operas like "As the World Turns." He gained fame in the late 1990s with his role in the "American Pie" film series, portraying a relatable and awkward teenager. His comedic talent led to roles in various romantic comedies and TV shows, including a notable stint on "Orange Is the New Black." Beyond acting, he has explored stand-up comedy and theater, showcasing his versatility.